|
U.S. PIRG Consumer Blog
« The Nation: Google: Search and Data Seizure |
Main
| PrivacyGuard- Just do nothing »
October 01, 2007
Countrywide Mortgage-- like negotiating with the Deathstar
In Gretchen Morgenson's story Can These Mortgages Be Saved? about Countrywide in the Sunday New York Times, every consumer and community advocate says the same thing: But borrower advocates who work with a broad array of lenders say that none make it harder to modify loans than Countrywide, the nation's largest mortgage originator and loan servicer. As pointed out by advocates in the story, Countrywide even deceptively pads its own modest borrower assistance efforts, by claiming that deals made in its own favor, to short sale (called a deed-in-lieu) homes and turn them back to Countrywide, are somehow modifications helping borrowers save their homes: "When you look under the surface, they are counting deeds-in-lieu as a modification," said Martin Eakes, chief executive of the Center for Responsible Lending, a nonprofit and nonpartisan research organization. "When you've taken someone's house, even without the foreclosure process, to count that as a modification is worse than fiction."
The story points out that, in general, consumers trapped in bad mortgages with other lenders also face difficulty, yet even government officials put a rosy face on the problem: Lenders, government officials and loan servicers, who take in borrowers' monthly mortgage payments, contend that troubled borrowers everywhere are being helped to stay in their homes by those overseeing their loans. But neither data nor anecdotal evidence supports this view. In today's New York Times, economist-columnist Paul Krugman has a follow-up: Enron's Second Coming?, pointing out that Countrywide kingpin Angelo Mozilo, who was paid $142 million last year, has "achieved the rare feat of victimizing three distinct groups": borrowers, investors and Countrywide's own stockholders. Krugman refers back to Morgenson's article: Why block mutually beneficial deals? As the article points out, Countrywide can make money from the fees it charges on foreclosures, while the losses from mortgages that could have been saved, but weren't, are borne by others. Meanwhile a listener comment to a Marketplace story on Public Citizen's new report on unfair credit card arbitration practices points out that -- in the end -- the Star Wars rebels defeated the evil Deathstar, twice. That's true, but let's hope the Jedi return and prevent Countrywide from blowing up a lot more neighborhoods first.
Posted by Ed Mierzwinski at October 1, 2007 05:23 AM
Post a comment
|