Ed's Blog

Weird Big Bank Trick Raises Price of Beer and Soda

By Ed Mierzwinski
Consumer Program Director

UPDATE August 8: In his New York Times column, Professor Simon Johnson discusses the extensive debate triggered by the Senate Banking Committee's recent hearing into Goldman's alleged manipulation of aluminum prices. Here is an excerpt from "Getting Big Banks Out of the Commodities Business."

"This may be the strangest debate we have had about banking in the United States in the last five years, because the answer is completely obvious: it is a new and very bad idea to allow big banks to also dominate any dimension of the commodities business. It is also not sustainable politically, and the big banks will soon have to divest themselves of these activities. [...] When you allow any companies both cheap government-backed financing and carte blanche to take over other sectors, what would you expect to happen? And if you allow any kind of unfair market power to develop, surely it would be a shock if this did not result in higher prices or less good service – or even some kind of manipulation."

ORIGINAL POST: What's raising the price of beer and soda? Hint: It's not the cost of hops or sugar. If complaints to regulators and Congress are accurate, it's the manipulation of aluminum markets by mega-bank Goldman Sachs.

Many of the failed, once-high-flying super-corporation Enron's alleged schemes to manipulate markets and defraud small investors and pension funds involved sham transactions with itself that the SEC alleged had "no economic substance." These "artifices" enabled Enron to falsely inflate its profits and unjustly enrich its insiders.

Now comes Goldman Sachs, updating a page from Enron's book. According to a major Sunday New York Times investigation called "A Shuffle of Aluminum, but to Banks, Pure Gold," by reporter David Kocieniewski, workers driving trucks and forklifts move tons of aluminum around and around its Detroit warehouses for what appears to be no reason at all.

"Two or three times a day, sometimes more, the drivers make the same circuits. They load in one warehouse. They unload in another. And then they do it again. This industrial dance has been choreographed by Goldman to exploit pricing regulations set up by an overseas commodities exchange, an investigation by The New York Times has found. The back-and-forth lengthens the storage time. And that adds many millions a year to the coffers of Goldman, which owns the warehouses and charges rent to store the metal. It also increases prices paid by manufacturers and consumers across the country. Tyler Clay, a forklift driver who worked at the Goldman warehouses until early this year, called the process 'a merry-go-round of metal.'"

At a U.S. Senate Banking subcommittee hearing yesterday chaired by Sherrod Brown (OH), an expert, Professor Saule T. Omarova of the University of North Carolina School of Law, confirmed the New York Times' analysis and testified that Goldman "has caused serious turbulence in the global market for aluminum, the second most widely used metal in the world after steel." She also explained that all the biggest mega-banks are branching out into the physical commodities markets. 

That "turbulence" Professor Omarova highlighted was brought home by a witness for a beer company hampered and frustrated by Goldman's alleged actions. From a followup by Edward Wyatt in today's New York Times:

"Major beverage companies have complained about the maneuvers. Tim Weiner, a MillerCoors executive, told the panel on Tuesday that while consumers might not think they have much at stake from tons of aluminum bars stored in a warehouse near Detroit, the actions of Goldman and others have raised prices, cost jobs and hindered innovation. [...] Imagine going to a liquor store to buy a case of beer, and taking it up to the cash register to pay, Mr. Weiner said. Then instead of taking the case of beer to your car, the clerk told you to visit the store’s warehouse, where you can retrieve the beer in 16 months."

Professor Omarova points out in her encyclopedic testimony (32 pages) that while the big banks have pushed the envelope between the letter and spirit of the law, that the practices, while not at all transparent, are not necessarily illegal.

She explains how the big banks have exploited loopholes created by both the Federal Reserve and Congress, including those established by the infamous and PIRG-opposed 1999 repeal of Depression-era legislation separating banking and commerce, which also helped trigger the 2008 economic collapse. She explains how cracks in that once solid wall between banking and commerce have been substantially widened into full-fledged breaches large enought to drive trucks, or oil tankers, through. She explains how the historic events of September 2008, when the surviving giant investment banks -- Goldman and Morgan Stanley -- were brought under the Federal safety net (because they were too big to fail), were actually a boon to the firms' efforts to expand their physical commodities activities.

She goes on to point out how in 2008 and 2009 JP Morgan Chase took advantage of "once-in -a-lifetime" opportunities to acquire the commodities assets of two failing investing banks, Bear Stearns and UBS, which essentially grandfathered JPMC into the business, too.

She explains that these big banks are involved not only in aluminum, but other physical commodities markets, including other metals, oil, asphalt, chemicals, oil tankers, mines, refineries, electricity production "and other things." She explains how the fuzzy language of the laws aids mega-bank efforts to expand their footprint and how the banks actively and successfully sought language to give them an "open-ended source of legal authority for banking organizations to engage in any commercial activities that may become feasible or potentially profitable in the future."

So if the banks are making more money, what's the problem? She further explains that not only do the physical commodities trading practices pose both reputational risk to an individual firm's safety and the risk of "contagion" to the entire financial system, they also raise important questions related to the principal policy arguments that led to the separation of banking and commerce: conflicts of interest that could lead to credit mis-allocation, the potential for market manipulation and higher consumer prices and the risk of an even greater concentration of economic and political power than the big banks already enjoy.

Professor Omarova's concerns were echoed by another witness, Joshua Rosner, a managing partner at Graham Fisher and Company, who argued that these and other mega-bank tactics are part of their strategy to increase revenue through "control of nonfinancial infrastructure assets."

The committee's hearing certainly drilled deeply into a variety of complex and technical issues. But, as is often the case, Senator Elizabeth Warren (MA) provided a clear summary, according to today's New York Times

“The notion that two of largest financial companies are adopting a business method pioneered by Enron,” she said, “suggests that this movie will not end well.”

In a separate followup in the New York Times today, Gretchen Morgenson and David Kocieniewski point out that:

"The Commodity Futures Trading Commission has taken the first step in an examination of warehouse operations that are controlled by Goldman Sachs, Glencore Xstrata, the Noble Group and others and used to store vast amounts of aluminum."

The banks may claim that "it's all legal." Certainly their phalanx of lobbyists and PR firms and their various political patrons will try to dismiss the significance of these important inquiries by Congress, major media and the CFTC. Yet, as Subcommittee Chairman Sherrod Brown (OH) explained yesterday:

“Ohio manufacturers and consumers should not have the price of their gas, beer, soft drinks, or electricity driven up by Wall Street speculators,” Brown said. “When Wall Street banks control the supply of both commodities and financial products, there's a potential for anti-competitive behavior and manipulation. It also exposes these megabanks - and the entire financial system - to undue risk from mine collapses, oil spills, and refinery explosions.”


I was suggested this website by my cousin. I am not sure whether this
post is written by him as no one else know such detailed about my problem.
You are wonderful! Thanks!

Feel free to visit my blog; <a href="http://writegoodstuff.co/discovering-fantastic-deals-on-garcinia-cambogi... Cambogia</a>

Thank you very much for a very useful article. Best of luck always to the author. Cipto Junaedy, Mobil Sedan COrolla,Mobil Sedan COrolla, Mobil Sedan COrolla, Cipto Junaedy

Thank you very much for a very useful article. Best of luck always to the author.

I am always searching online for articles that can help me. There is obviously a lot to know about this. I think you made some good points in Features also. Keep working, great job! - http://www.memefloristsolo.com/

Nonton Siaran Pertandingan Sepak Bola Online di NOBARTV.COM

Nonton Siaran TV Bola Online http://goo.gl/P9u3mx di NOBARTV.COM
Kabar Berita Bola Online Terbaru Hari Ini http://goo.gl/lErqKY di NOBARTV.COM
Kumpulan Jadwal Pertandingan TV Bola Online http://goo.gl/QkgLyy di NOBARTV.COM
Kumpulan Kabar Berita Harian Bola Online Terbaru http://goo.gl/b278O2 di NOBARTV.COM

I read that Post and got it fine and informative. Please share more like that...
secret survey system review

Really solid, awesome, fact-filled information here. Your posts NEVER ever disappoint, and that certainly holds true here as well. You always make for an interesting read. Can you tell I'm impressed? :) Keep up the fantastic articles.
Orlando Fl Pressure Washing

I got what you intend, regards for putting up.Woh I am happy to find this website through google. "Money is the most egalitarian force in society. It confers power on whoever holds it." by Roger Starr.
http://lonely-cheating-wives.net famous cheating women

Appreciate it for all your efforts that you have put in this. very interesting info . "Names are changed more readily than doctrines, and doctrines more readily than ceremonies." by Thomas Love Peacock.
http://datingcheatingwives.net/kansas-dating-cheating-wives/index.htm cheating husbands kansas house wives, http://femaleswinger.net/nevada-female-swinger/index.htm bisexual females nevada swinging couples, http://dateadultfinder.net/michigan-date-adult/index.htm totally free date finder detroit michigan emo date finder, http://adultmatch-maker.com/oklahoma-adult-matches/index.htm adult match finder oklahoma on line dating, http://adultonlinepersonals.net/washington-adult-online-personals/index.htm online dating washington online sex personals

5 things to do today features posts on Travel, Food, Celebrities and VIP Events, Launch Parties, Restaurant reviews, Books, Technology, Arts and Entertainment, Luxury and General Lifestyle and……………much more. I work on my own and with a variety of media/public relation companies... SEO

You have raised an important issue..Thanks for sharing..I would like to read more current affairs from this blog..keep posting..
Palm Beach Fl Pressure Washing

It is a training course that teaches you the strategy of selling items online by making strong relationships with the customers. You will get to learn that how do you lure people and encourage them to purchase. FB Cash Method review

The easy to implement concepts and techniques taught in the Girlfriend In A Week system are based on Jonathan's own real world experience teaching hundreds of men how to meet and attract amazing women and hold the key to unlocking the "girlfriend code".girlfriend in a week book reviews

The review found no studies that directly measured the effectiveness of electronik sigara in smoking cessation, and examined two published studies that indirectly considered the issue by measuring the effect of the product on cravings and other short-term indicators.elektronik sigara

Voyance et médium sont indisociables. La voyance a besoin d'un expert pour être comprise. A ce titre, les médiums travaillent sur plusieurs plans qui sont le plan terrestre et l'au-delà pour interpréter leur voyance. Une voyance de qualité amenée par un médium donne des résultats surprenants.voyance medium

The compartments are big enough for any pair of my (men’s)size 12 shoes. The bottom of each compartment is reinforced well enough and it seems sturdily built. I’m using one for shoes and the other for sweaters. It’s exactly what I wanted and needed to empty the floor of my closet so I can walk in freely, and get the shelves uncluttered. I’d recommend them.Closet shoe rack

South Africa is brimmed with the excitement and joy of World Cup and if you want to be a core fan of any team then it is time to know about the best teams. I would prefer Spain due to many reasons which will convince you also.

Recently I came across your blog and read along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I do not know what to say except that I liked reading. Nice blog. buy high pr backlinks

Silverchair Learning Logins is for your Login Questions. It seems like anytime you go online you need to login to a website and the process can often seem to be a huge mystery. When it comes to the login processes for your credit cards, bank accounts and favorite websites, the process should never be hard to figure out... Silverchair Learning Logins

Great post full of useful tips! My site is fairly new and I am also having a hard time getting my readers to leave comments. Analytics shows they are coming to the site but I have a feeling “nobody wants to be first”.

Our complimentary airport/ rail pick up is a boon for any family, small or large, arriving Delhi with frayed nerves, possibly hair standing out on skin and head. And there is the utter joy family and kids get when they tuck in our scrumptious food.budget hotel in delhi

James feels that deenzlist has created a new environment in which businesses can communicate directly with potential customers. He believes the introduction of using students as promoters, businesses could see benefits in sales and potentially a "fad" product on campuses. He feels utilizing student as promoters could bode well for businesses due to the fact that students typically are interested in what their fellow peers are buying. Business promotion

It looks like you spend a lot of effort and time on your blog. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles.

Bouncy castles feel safe for kids if supervised effectively by the responsible adult.The existence of a supervisor is required to make sure that kids of different ages tend not to bounce at the same time. Fun is guaranteed with our castles! http://bouncycastlehireinbirmingham.weebly.com/

James feels that deenzlist has created a new environment in which businesses can communicate directly with potential customers. He believes the introduction of using students as promoters, Urdu Shayari

Nice blog post. I can't believe that I actually reading your posts and commenting on them to let you know that I like this. You've been my idol since I was a kid and it's a dream come true for me to read your articles. I look forward to reading more of your amazing blog post. http://blog.kontorimoobel.ee/

Get Girls From Home review, ebook FAQ, and PDF download guide that provides an insider's look at the program and answers frequently asked questions about JT Tran's unique and highly popular online attraction guide.get get girls from home reviews

It stands for search engine optimization and is an essential part of any effective marketing strategy. In this e-age, where anything and everything can be found online, and where people depend on search engines like Google more than anything else, it is important to gain popularity online and become a front runner.http://www.omahaseoservices.com/

The course was filmed during an actual 2 day seminar put on by Christian, so I've broken things into 2 posts, one for each day of the actual seminar.http://girlfriendactivationsystemreview.org/

I want you to thank for your time of this wonderful read!!! I definately enjoy every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff of your blog a must read blog!!!! Ciri Gejala Penyakit | Modifikasi Motor Satria Fu

Written for consumers by a consumer, this fan site includes a fun and informative Blood Pressure Solution review, ebook FAQ, and PDF download guide that provides an insider's look at the program and answers frequently asked questions about Ken Burge's unique and highly popular hypertension treatment guide.https://rebelmouse.com/bloodpressuresolutionreview

The Drama Method Ebook: Outrageous, Illogical, And Ultra-Clever Tactics For Using Drama To Trigger Irresistible Love And Affection In Any Man drama method aaron fox ebook

agen casino sbobet terpercaya http://bandar365.com agen judi taruhan bola nih

Great post full of useful tips! My site is fairly new and I am also having a hard time getting my readers to leave comments. Analytics shows they are coming to the site but I have a feeling “nobody wants to be first”. About National Benefit Authority

If you choose the other options, go to Gmail–>Contacts on the left upper corner, and when the left sidebar appear click Import Contacts. In this case Gmail will ask you to select a file (CSV files for example). This is when you have, for example, an Outlook account and you want to import the contacts from there.create a gmail account

Recently I came across your blog and read along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I do not know what to say except that I liked reading. Nice blog. text your ex back review

This is a great post ! it was very informative. I look forward to reading more of your website. I made sure to bookmark your website so I can come back later. I enjoyed every moment of reading it. תקליטנים לחתונות

The digital landscape has changed tremendously over the last decade but Charlotte SEO still remains to be one of the best marketing strategies on the internet. Everybody is Tweeting or on Facebook and the only way to be noticed is by ranking on the 1st page of search engines for the people to notice what you are doing or offering.read the review: ge.tt

It's a great pleasure reading your post.It's full of information I am looking for and I love to post a comment that "The content of your post is awesome" Great work!masaj

Hello, I have browsed most of your posts. This post is where I got the most useful information for my research. Thanks for posting, maybe we can see more on this. Are you aware of any other websites on this subject.
how can i turn a girl on over text

Written for consumers by a consumer, this fan site includes a fun and informative 3 Second Sexual Attraction 2.0 review, ebook FAQ, and PDF download guide that provides an insider's look at the program and answers frequently asked questions about Mehow's unique and highly popular attraction guide. https://www.rebelmouse.com/3secondsexualattractionreview/

Includes a collection of Aaron Fox Drama Method reviews, PDF download information, and tips on how to make men desire you from around the web.review and program preview

. I thought I would leave my first comment. I do not know what to say except that I liked reading. Nice blog buy high pr blog comments


Priority Action

The overuse of antibiotics on factory farms is threatening the effectiveness of lifesaving antibiotics. Call on the Food and Drug Administration to put an end to the worst practices.

Support Us

Your donation supports U.S. PIRG’s work to stand up for consumers on the issues that matter, especially when powerful interests are blocking progress.

Consumer Alerts

Join our network and stay up to date on our campaigns, get important consumer updates and take action on critical issues.