Ed's Blog

We Join FTC Event on Big Data E-Scores

By Ed Mierzwinski
Consumer Program Director

Companies on the Internet are tracking you with vastly powerful Big Data algorithms to determine what to sell you, for how much and what financial opportunities (loans, accounts, credit cards) to offer you. Today at 10am, I join an FTC workshop on Alternative Scoring Products to debate the transparency and fairness of the system. Privacy and technology experts from industry, academia and the public interest will also participate. They include Professor Joe Turow of the Annenberg School of Communication at Penn, author of The Daily You: How the New Advertising Industry is Defining Your Identity and Your Worth (link is to an interview on NPR's Fresh Air with Terry Gross), and Ashkan Soltani, a privacy and technology consultant (formerly to the FTC) who also helped the Wall Street Journal crack behavioral tracking, scoring and dynamic pricing codes for its award-winning "What They Know" series. You can attend or watch online or watch it as an archive after the event.

The FTC has published a short blog explaining predictive scoring. Along with Jeff Chester of the Center for Digital Democracy, we have submitted a detailed comment (scroll down to see the full pdf) explaining our views. Only a few other comments have been posted so far, but you can file your own comments (due by 21 April) after you watch the workshop.

For many years, financial marketing that was based on your financial profile (your credit report) was conducted under strict "prescreening rules" of the Fair Credit Reporting Act of 1970. Companies could use your financial profile only for credit or insurance marketing (not general target or direct marketing) and if you replied to the offer, they had to make a "firm offer of credit." Importantly, if you choose to reject this use of your credit report,  you have the right say no, or opt-out, to protect your privacy.

But in the new Big Data world, the firms claim that their uses of information don't "determine eligibility" and so don't trigger your FCRA rights; so, they assert,  they don't have to give you any disclosure of their practices or the right to say no. They claim this even though their financial marketing offers -- essentially prescreening on rocket fuel -- are now being made in real-time (in hundredths of a second) and aren't based only on their compilation of financial data. Their algorithm also may include the powerful new added dimension of your location (from your mobile phone), as well as other data bits, all analyzed together in milli-seconds to decide where to lead you and what to show you and what to offer you. In our view, the vast majority of these instant decisions are still based largely on information that amounts to financial profiling and designed to encourage you to accept financial offers, whether good or bad for you.

For example, some of the non-transparent, deceptive pages you are led to on the Internet when you type "I need a loan," may appear to be lenders, but aren't. These websites are actually "lead generators," that ask you a few questions to determine your value and then auction you off to the highest bidder, often an online payday lender or for-profit school. Lead generators are the target of numerous enforcement inquiries, including by New York.

In a nutshell, if the protections offered by a regulated prescreening system for financial marketing are diluted by a switch to scores generated using largely unregulated Internet algorithms created through the sharing of cookies and all these other tracking bits between and among a vast interconnected network of business-to-business firms that consumers don't know about or do business with, consumers will be harmed.

As the authoritative National Consumer Law Center pointed out in its recent report on "Big Data," the Big Data algorithms, which may not be accurate or have any relation to your creditworthiness, also may implicate your rights under the Equal Credit Opportunity Act, which prohibits discrimination on the basis of gender, race, age or other factors. Further, fellow workshop panelist Pam Dixon of the World Privacy Forum will point out today that some of the algorithms used by some players in the Big Data universe are targeting consumers based on "vulnerability-based marketing."

Here is a summary of the joint U.S. PIRG/Center for Digital Democracy comment:

The growing use of so-called “e-scores” —a form of invisible (to the consumer) online ratings — can help determine our credit worthiness, “lifetime value,” or even the prices we pay. These e-scores can be used to blacklist or engage in discriminatory practices against individuals or even groups of consumers. We are aware that there are numerous online scores being generated for a variety of generally non-controversial uses, including predicting identity theft or fraud. However, we remain concerned that the largest and most important uses of online scoring are to substitute for the highly-regulated pre-screening regime that for years has governed the use of consumer credit reports for marketing purposes. Its proponents claim that the files developed are not on individual consumers, but on clusters of consumers. Its proponents claim online scores are simply a method for establishing audiences for serving ads. Not subject to the Fair Credit Reporting Act FCRA) regulation, they assert, are scores and other products that identify consumers on an aggregate basis (which for them means information narrowed to a small cluster of households at the ZIP+4 level) or consumers not named by name. We disagree with these representations and commend FTC for its inquiry.

CDD and U.S. PIRG also explain our work in a recent Suffolk University Law Review article "Selling Consumers, Not Lists." Probably the best news resource on E-scores is the 2012 New York Times article by Natasha Singer, "Secret E-Scores Chart Consumers’ Buying Power."

I am looking forward to the debate. You can attend or watch online.


This is a good post! Well done and I believe it will be better in future..
Full Pc Games

it's much easier to get approved for a $50k line of credit compared to a $100k line of credit simply because of the documentation and amount of financials required on larger credit lines. Most banks only require a low 5 bank rating, a favorable business credit rating
Jasa Seo
Pakar Seo
Rental Mobil Solo
Sewa Mobil Solo
Cara Cepat Hamil
Agar Cepat Hamil
Agen Obat Pembesar
Obat Perangsang Wanita
Obat Pembesar Payudara
Boneka Full Body Elektrik
Agen Kondom Duri Silikon
Agen Obat Kuat Herbal
Obat Perangsang Wanita
Obat Perangsang Wanita
Boss Obat Kuat

South Africa is brimmed with the excitement and joy of World Cup and if you want to be a core fan of any team then it is time to know about the best teams. I would prefer Spain due to many reasons which will convince you also.

Despite these improvements, not all toys on store shelves are tested by the Commission and parents still need to take care to seek out safe toys. Our Trouble in Toyland survey found five major hazards in the toys we surveyed: http://goo.gl/QX1YL2 http://kwn.me/p243
http://goo.gl/G1cGxl http://goo.gl/Ibe4n0
http://goo.gl/dKoer7 http://kwn.me/p244 Precisely what a few clearance about ones v-beck with the - it looks like . Voting rights were the big issue in committee last week. Keep an eye out for updates as we move forward! Every day, our families are bombarded by a toxic soup of chemicals found in consumer products, in air, food and water pollution. Maryland PIRG supports legislation that at www.muhammadridwan.web.id

This is a very good tips especially to those new to blogosphere, brief and accurate information… Thanks for sharing this one. A must read article.
http://junaysukses.blogspot.com/2014/05/tips-blogger-pemula.html - Tips Akurat Untuk Blogger Pemula

http://junaysukses.blogspot.com/2014/05/kursus-seo-internet-marketing-te... - Kursus SEO dan Internet Marketing Terbaik di Jakarta

http://junaysukses.blogspot.com/2014/05/tips-web-marketing-buat-usaha-ke... - Tips Web Marketing "Pemasaran" Buat Usaha Kecil Anda

http://junaysukses.blogspot.com/2014/05/kata-cinta.html - Kata Cinta

Testing http://mahirseogoogle.blogspot.com/2014/06/adro.html ADRO TEXTILE Konveksi Murah Indonesia – Tlp 081362666444 !
http://clorot.blogspot.com/2014/04/kursus.html Kursus SEO dan Internet Marketing Terbaik di Jakarta

Age has given me the gift of me; it just gave me what I was always longing for, which was to get to be the woman I've already dreamt of being. Which is somebody who can do rest and do hard work and be a really constant companion, a constant, tender-hearted wife to myself.
http://hargasony-id.blogspot.com AND http://arbnew.blogspot.com/ . Your rewriting reduced the length and also improved clarity of the sentences. Most importantly, you kept the major points, making them very clear and smooth. I do appreciate your help
http://hargasony-id.blogspot.com/2014/07/hosting-unlimited-dan-domain-mu... AND http://hargasony-id.blogspot.com/2014/07/vizzyus-safety-url-monetize.html

http://fb.me/2nvGcPdzH gudangpoker
http://fb.me/2pTZGdVrG saranapoker
http://fb.me/38wdA8PG7 bundapoker
http://fb.me/3a5cT36FS nagalaut

Yup, that'll do it. You have my aproeciatipn. A plseniagly rational answer. Good to hear from you

Share lengkap dan mendalam tentang unit link terbaik di Indonesia Commowealth Life investra link kini sudah ada di : http://kiranbanget.blogspot.com/2014/03/unit-link-terbaik-di-indonesia.html . Unit link pun dapat anda dapatkan di review ini. Dan untuk yang ingin beli properti dan yang butuh info tentang Cipto Junaedy juga ada di http://kiranbanget.blogspot.com/2014/04/cipto-junaedy.html

I think, I got this time of news at http://adeptcareer.in. This is a really good information posted by the author.

Cipto Junaedy nama yang tidak asing bagi dunia property di Indonesia, sesuai dengan nama CIPTO yang berarti mencipta atau penggagas sebuah penemuan dalam arti Menciptakan "Strategy Beli Property Tanpa Utang" maka sangat tepat sekali nama........ http://anemath.blogspot.com/2014/06/cipto-junaedy.html Cipto Junaedy mempunyai image jagonya

it's much easier to get approved for a $50k line of credit compared to a $100k line of credit simply because of the documentation and amount of financials required on larger credit lines. Most banks only require a low 5 bank rating, a favorable business credit rating


Berbagai Informasi kesehatan http://goo.gl/zqykxV

Berbagai Informasi kesehatan http://goo.gl/zqykxV

thanks for information http://goo.gl/ZhUS88

thanks for information http://goo.gl/ZhUS88

terimakasih infonya http://goo.gl/C0U2MZ

terimakasih infonya http://goo.gl/C0U2MZ

selamat siang, sukses http://goo.gl/PEFHEV

selamat siang, sukses http://goo.gl/PEFHEV

terimakasih infonya http://goo.gl/ly3Ddl

terimakasih infonya http://goo.gl/ly3Ddl

Thanks u for sharing and providing us the insights. Klik Disini It is really helpful for me. Klik Disini Also would like to share the view of mines: Klik Disini Thanks a lot

Thanks u for sharing and providing us the insights. Klik Disini It is really helpful for me. Klik Disini Also would like to share the view of mines: Klik Disini Thanks a lot

Klik Klik Klik http://goo.gl/EpsRZx

Klik Klik Klik http://goo.gl/EpsRZx

terimakasih infonya sangat bermanfaat http://goo.gl/RreZnG

terimakasih infonya sangat bermanfaat http://goo.gl/RreZnG

Super-Duper blog! I am loving it!! Will be back later to read some more. I am bookmarking your feeds also.
Pulau Tidung Paket
Paket Wisata Pulau Tidung
Paket Pulau Tidung
Travel Pulau Tidung
Pulau Seribu
Wisata Pulau Tidung

Thanks for the info, maybe I can use this ended my tufted marketing and I've been use untold anulus media in run a interaction and they someone existing a big amend on me. Bandar Bola


Priority Action

The overuse of antibiotics on factory farms is threatening the effectiveness of lifesaving antibiotics. Call on the Food and Drug Administration to put an end to the worst practices.

Support Us

Your donation supports U.S. PIRG’s work to stand up for consumers on the issues that matter, especially when powerful interests are blocking progress.

Consumer Alerts

Join our network and stay up to date on our campaigns, get important consumer updates and take action on critical issues.