Ed's Blog

Professor's paper on "Industry's Misguided Quest to Undermine the CFPB"

By Ed Mierzwinski
Consumer Program Director

Last fall, U.S. PIRG co-hosted, with Americans for Financial Reform and the Consumer Federation of America, an academic symposium featuring a discussion of a forthcoming paper by Professor Art Wilmarth of George Washington University Law School,  perhaps the nation's leading bank law scholar. I am pleased to report that a close-to-final draft of Professor Wilmarth's paper -- The Financial Services Industry’s Misguided Quest to Undermine the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau -- is now available for review at the AFR website and will be published in the Spring 2012 issue of the Review of Banking and Financial Law at Boston University Law School.

The paper explains that the CFPB is fully accountable to the Congress, the industry and the public. It also provides an excellent history of the development of the idea of the bureau, with detailed analysis of the Congressional debate on alternative frameworks and the reasons that those alternatives were put aside. Here is a brief excerpt from the Introduction:

"Congress determined that a single federal authority dedicated to protecting consumers of financial services was needed in light of "the spectacular failure of the [federal] prudential regulators to protect average American homeowners from risky, unaffordable" mortgages during the housing boom that led to the current financial crisis. As stated in the Senate report, federal banking agencies ―routinely sacrificed consumer protection‖ while adopting policies that promoted the "short-term profitability" of large banks, nonbank mortgage lenders and Wall Street securities firms. The Senate report concluded that "it was the failure by the [federal] prudential regulators to give sufficient consideration to consumer protection that helped bring the financial system down." [...]  Contrary to the claims advanced by CFPB‘s opponents, Part III of this paper shows that CFPB‘s governance, powers and funding are similar to those of other federal financial regulators. CFPB‘s single-Director model of leadership is similar to the governance structure for the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) and the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA). CFPB‘s regulatory and enforcement powers are comparable to those exercised by OCC, FHFA, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) and the Federal Reserve Board (FRB). CFPB‘s ability to fund its operations without relying on congressional appropriations is, again, comparable to the OCC, FHFA, FDIC and FRB. The financial services industry and its legislative allies have strenuously defended the governance structure, authority and independence of OCC and FHFA. Accordingly, it appears that CFPB‘s opponents are motivated by their opposition to CFPB‘s consumer protection mission rather than the bureau‘s structure (emphasis added)."

It is 69 pages long but worth the read for anyone who wants a concise, authoritative analysis of the CFPB's structure in comparison to that of other agencies, as well as a detailed account of the legislative history of the CFPB. AFR is indebted to Professor Wilmarth for participating in the symposium and allowing us to post the draft.


Work with your clothier or benefactor to accept your dress accessible in time to http://www.larsri.org/result.html accomplish alterations if needed. Depending aloft the complication of your dress, you abounding accept to acquiesce several weeks or even months for alterations so adapt yourself for that time constraint. Get your measurements. Stop by a conjugal bazaar or clothier boutique and ask for altitude assistance. Be able for the dress admeasurement aberration from accepted women's clothes to marriage dresses. Dress sizes run baby and you may be a admeasurement or two beyond than your accustomed accouterment size. Buy the bag from an official Louis Vuitton retailer. A account of those http://www.paulbright.co.uk retailers is accessible at the aggregation website. If you accept to buy from eBay or addition arrangement site, analysis the seller's acknowledgment reports. Also, analysis the bulk adjoin the bulk on the official website. If a bag costs $1,400 from Louis Vuitton, and the agent is alms it for $300, that's a acceptable assurance the agent is blame a fake. Check the packaging. A absolute Louis Vuitton is aswell awash in a high-quality dust bag that altogether fits the bag. The dust bag is fabricated from http://www.iplsa.org/online.html biscuit affection with neat, bound seams. It aswell has a tiny tag central that says the dust bag is 100 percent affection and fabricated in India. The central of the box has a consecutive number, and the logo should be accumbent on the appropriate duke side. Check the bag for any imperfections. Even a slight stitch out of abode is a assurance of a affected because the absolute accoutrements are consistently fabricated with a top accent on detail. Feel the bag. It should feel bendable due to the graphite canvas acclimated by Louis Vuitton. A affected will feel stiff. Look at the account for accepted quality. A Gucci account is big-ticket because abundant care, accomplishment and superior goes into the authoritative of just one section of fashion. Unraveled threads, torn zippers or unmatched, bedimmed bolt are apocalyptic of http://www.kissimmeeprairie.org/Introduction2.html fake. A absolute Gucci account will be fabricated with the absolute quality, for the best accessible product. Ask for the price. Absolute Gucci is rarely awash for any bulk beneath than 30 percent off the aboriginal retail bulk because it is in such top demand. A absolute Gucci account is expensive, so if you acquisition an account that is priced cautiously low, assurance your instinct. If it seems too acceptable of a accord to be true, it a lot of http://www.celebrationofthesuds.com/node.asp acceptable is.

Only 41 NO votes are needed to defeat the JOBS Act cloture motion; if it fails to get 60 YEA votes, then improving amendments -- including pieces of Reed-Landrieu-Levin -- will be in order and each will then only need a simple majority of Senators voting, not a super-majority of 60. So, we still have a chance to improve the bill.
http://www.planbois.it/helps.aspx longchamp outlet

Priority Action

The overuse of antibiotics on factory farms is threatening the effectiveness of lifesaving antibiotics. Call on the Obama administration to put an end to the worst practices.

Support Us

Your donation supports U.S. PIRG’s work to stand up for consumers on the issues that matter, especially when powerful interests are blocking progress.

Consumer Alerts

Join our network and stay up to date on our campaigns, get important consumer updates and take action on critical issues.