Blog

Problems With Privatized Law Enforcement's New Frontier

By Phineas Baxandall
Senior Analyst for Tax & Budget Policy

A company contracts with your city to search through your individual garbage. If they find other improperly sorted waste, they send you a municipal citation and collect a portion of the fine. Another company surveys your house for zoning violations. The cash-strapped city is glad for the extra revenue and brags that compliance with housing code is on the rise. They contract with another company that installs cameras in the red lights at busy intersections. After turning right at a red light without coming to a complete stop behind the line, the company sends you a ticket in the mail for $156.

Only one of these things happen presently and it's stirring up hornets' nests of outrage around the country. As many as 700 communities across as many as 28 states contract out to private companies that install and operate automated red-light or speed cameras and then send tickets to the owners of cars caught on film for legal violations.

One in five Americans lives in a jurisdiction that outsources traffic ticketing this way, according to a newly released report from the U.S. Public Interest Research Group, titled "Caution: Red Light Cameras Ahead; The Risks of Privatizing Traffic Law Enforcement and How to Protect the Public." And a report released by the Justice Department suggests this trend may accelerate under the twin pressures of budget pressure and intense lobbying.

Cash-starved municipalities privatizing law enforcement? Companies with business models that depend on catching increasing numbers of Americans for crimes? This can be a terrible combination.

The report finds a number of abuses. For example, the people of Baytown, Texas were confronted with a breach of contract lawsuit after they voted in November 2010 to terminate their camera system. A lengthy legal battle ensued, and the settlement required the town to pay $1 million in exchange for the removal of the cameras. Bell Gardens, California signed a contract with Redflex Traffic Systems that allowed the camera vendor to penalize the city if it decided to alter the duration of yellow lights at monitored intersections. Some studies have even found that red-light cameras can increase injuries.

Since company profits depend on driving up ticket revenue, it's not surprising that companies also wield political power to influence local decisions. According to the Orlando Sun Sentinel, the company American Traffic Solutions spent over $1.3 million on lobbying activities in the past four years. Since 2006, Redflex hired over 100 registered lobbyists to represent their interests in 18 states.

These kinds of abuses have sparked a citizen backlash. Sixteen municipalities have held public referenda against these programs, all successful. Major cities like Los Angeles, Atlanta, Raleigh and Houston have rejected red-light cameras after initially approving them.

Almost every state with red-light cameras has spurred citizen opposition groups with mad-as-hell names like "BanTheCams," "Wrong on Red," and "Highway Robbery."

Drivers of course should obey the law and have always griped about tickets, but Americans rightly feel outraged when they believe others game the system to use the law as a way to pick their pockets. If people are forced to pay fines, they want to know that police charges against them are fair. They get incensed to discover that contracts with private camera vendors can dictate policing and safety practices even when the public has weighed in against those practices. It's not that police are entirely removed from camera ticketing -- they still must view the photo and stamp their final approval on the final approval -- but the judgment of public officials is removed and after-the-fact.

People can also rail against camera vendor contracts that seem unreasonable or motivated by greed. For all their human frailties, police officers are expected to act justly, not merely to follow contractual limits when exploiting people. Back in 1980, social scientist Michael Lipsky coined the phrase "street-level bureaucrats" to describe how front-line public servants like police and firefighters inevitably must exercise judgment to decide how to translate the law. Police treat a driver that races through a red light at a crowded school zone differently from a right turn at a deserted corner in the middle of the night.

It's not that automated ticketing technology is fundamentally evil. If a city has recurrent problems with injuries from red-light running at particular intersections and they have already tried alternative measures such as lengthening yellow light intervals and improving visibility, then an automated deterrent may prevent future injuries. The program can even be operated fully by the public. The Illinois State Police operate their own program using cameras to ticket dangerous speeders near highway work sites. That program has been without controversy.

The report suggests basic reforms to prevent problems with automated traffic enforcement contracting. Local officials considering the use of red-light traffic cameras should:

  • Put public safety first in decisions regarding enforcement of traffic laws -- this includes evaluating privatized law enforcement camera systems against alternative safety options without regard to potential revenues.
  • Ensure that contract language is free from potential conflicts of interest.
  • Avoid direct or indirect incentives for vendors that are based on the volume of tickets or fines.
  • Retain complete public control over all transportation policy decisions.
  • Retain the option to withdraw from a contract early if dissatisfied with service or its effects.
  • Ensure that the process of contracting with vendors is completely open, with ample opportunity for meaningful public participation.
  • Make information about the operation of privatized traffic law enforcement fully transparent and accessible online.
  • Not permit information about individual vehicles and drivers gathered by camera vendors to be used for any purpose other than the enforcement of traffic laws.
  • Consider establishing state standards to help cities avoid contracting for automated enforcement systems that are not justified or when alternatives make more sense.

If municipalities don't create better ground rules for privatizing traffic law enforcement, Americans will become even more cynical about government's ability to protect the common good. When powerful corporations line up to produce revenue from fines on citizens, we need strong public protections against abuse.

Especially before some company contracts to look through our garbage.

Comments

I've found this to give quick nearly instant relief.

http://santa-cruz-dating.com/forum/viewtopic.php?p=29031#29031
http://demo.theconceptmakers.com/projovenrd/index.php?option=com_fireboa...
http://togetho.ru/clad/viewtopic.php?f=19&t=20986
http://forums.thesurfacetablet.net/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=43400
http://mychurchorchestra.com/community/survey/comment-page-1/#comment-1933

In addition , being Michael Vick, a franchise player and superstar, he had the absolute most to lose, and that he did lose it all. Your lawyer should really be ready to cross-examine these supposed specialists aggressively. http://ezinearticles.com/?The-Facts-About-Vaginal-Yeast-Infections&id=70...

Discussing your targets in your admissions essay is a great way of telling the admissions panel that you do have concrete plans after law school.

I know your expertise on this. I must say we should have an online discussion on this. Writing only comments will close the discussion straight away! And will restrict the benefits from this information.
http://fb.me/2I8E9Uu9h
http://fb.me/1z6FGBNTX
http://goo.gl/xqhLHF
http://fb.me/32LE7izdi
http://vo.to/ciptojunaedy
http://vo.to/mobilsedancorolla

People and negotiators are so careful nowadays especially if it is a public content and matter. There is no surprise is that; a published material is so tightly concerned with the mortgage business party. Because if there are flaws in the settlement, that means public will make them pay.
http://rosie.besaba.com/alfamart-official-partner-merchandise-piala-duni...
http://maskodoq.blogspot.com/2013/07/CiptoJunaedy.html
http://maskodoq.blogspot.com/2014/03/unit-link-terbaik-di-indonesia.html
http://etnisjawa.blogspot.com/2013/08/apakah-cipto-junaedy-bohong.html
http://rosie.besaba.com/situs-online-terbaik-terpercaya/

content and matter. There is no surprise is that; a published material is so tightly concerned with the mortgage business party. Because if there are flaws in the settlement, that means public will make them pay. http://www.blachyperforowane.net/

While it is a misleading to impose a trajectory of "evolution" on a band that stubbornly resists aesthetic stasis, that re-imagines its own sound with every subsequent offering www.slubnydom.pl

You have a clever yet attractive way of writing. Easily, the article is actually the best topic on this registry related issue. Thank you for another informative blog. Where else could I get that kind of info written in such a perfect way? - http://www.tokobungajogja.net/

Only one of these things happen presently and it's stirring up hornets' nests of outrage around the country. As many as 700 communities across as many as 28 states contract out to private companies that install and operate automated red-light or speed cameras and then send tickets to the owners of cars caught on film for legal violations. Citibank opinie

many as 28 states contract out to private companies that install and operate automated red-light or speed cameras and then send tickets to the owners of cars caught on film for legal violations.home

enforcement? Companies with business models that depend on catching increasing numbers of Americans for crimes? This can be a terrible combination.slava.fi/lainaohjeet/pikavippi-heti/

I'm so happy to read this topic. This is the kind of manual that needs to be given and not the accidental misinformation that's at the other web. Appreciate your article this greatest topic.

You can read entry http://arentin.blogspot.com/2014/02/unit-link-terbaik-di-indonesia-commo... Unit link terbaik di Indonesia Commonwealth Life investra link , also don't forget click useful entry http://arisnbw.blogspot.com Unit link terbaik also cool entry http://www.postingku.com Cipto Junaedy also entry http://arisnbw.blogspot.com/2013/10/ciptojunaedy.html Cipto also cool article http://arentin.blogspot.com/2013/05/cipto-junaedy.html Cipto Junaedy that's good also useful article http://www.aa-gallery.co.id kerajinan kuningan also useful article http://www.aagallery.co.id kerajinan. Don't for get it!

wow this good but ,http://hackspix.com/110-hay-day-hack-unlimited-diamonds-coins-vouchers/ I like your post and good pics may be any peoples not like because defrent mind all poepl

kerajinan kuningan also useful article http://www.aagallery.co.id kerajinan. Don't for get it!The Antique Wine Company – A Listly List

content and matter. There is no surprise is that; a published material is so tightly concerned with the mortgage business party. garcinia cambogia dr oz

SarcasticFringehead The difference was that back when people used to do all these things themselves, nobody had jobs. Growing/cooking food and making your own clothes/furnishings WERE your job.website

Wow, cool post. I'd like to write like this too - taking time and real hard work to make a great article. but I put things off too much and never seem to get started. Thanks though. - Susu Kolostrum

Only one of these things happen presently and it's stirring up hornets' nests of outrage around the country. As many as 700 communities across as many as 28 states contract out to private companies that install and operate automated red-light youtube

municipal citation and collect a portion of the fine. Another company surveys your house for zoning violations. The cash-strapped city is glad for the extra revenue and brags that compliance with link

For decades, the prevailing model was to charge for upfront license fees coupled with high margin maintenance fees. In many cases, as much as 90% of the entire system was paid for before the newspaper even went live. kunststoff firma

if it is a public content and matter. There is no surprise is that; a published material is so tightly concerned with the mortgage business party. Because if there are flaws in the settlement, that means public will make them pay. click here

The cash-strapped city is glad for the extra revenue and brags that compliance with housing code is on the rise. They contract with another company that installs cameras in the red lights at busy intersections. After turning right at a red light without coming to a complete stop behind the line, the company sends you a ticket in the mail for $156. farby palette opinie

After reading your article I was amazed. So informative things are provided here, I loved what you've done here. The design is elegant, your content classy. Yet, you've got an edginess to what you're offering here. Ill definitely come back for more if you keep this up. Don't lose hope if not too many people see your vision, know you've got a fan right here who values what you've got to say and the way you've presented yourself. Good on you! - Toko Bunga Jakarta

I loved what you've done here. The design is elegant, your content classy. Yet, you've got an edginess to what you're offering here. Ill definitely come back for more if you keep this up. Don't lose hope if not too many people see your vision, know you've got a fan right here who values what you've got to say and the way you've presented yourself. Good on you! - Toko Bunga di Surabaya

The design is elegant, your content classy. Yet, you've got an edginess to what you're offering here. Ill definitely come back for more if you keep this up. the advantage

When you are receiving Orthodontic treatment with any Orthodontist it’s normal to expect some level of difficulty with brushing your teeth. The size and location of the braces will cause this difficulty. should you buy it...visit this site... glass cover for iphone 5

None of the lowest bid; responsiveness, and former employees of
it by taking advantage of the most suitable type of work for him
to do the parties.palette deluxe

Developments in Zimbabwean politics will this week see President Robert Mugabe’s Zanu (PF) government assume office faced with the daunting task of revitalising infrastructural deficiencies which have progressively deteriorated over the pa buy dofollow blog comments

You have a clever yet attractive way of writing. Hey, people utilized to write great posts.Thank you very much for a very useful article. Best of luck always to the author.personal training online

You have a clever yet attractive way of writing. Hey, people utilized to write great posts.Thank you very much for a very useful article. Best of luck always to the author Online Personal Training

he underlying assumption being of course “they’ve done OK so far, we can assume they will continue”. Continuing to make this assumption may be a big mistake.bobofrut konkurs

if it is a public content and matter. There is no surprise is that; a published material is so tightly concerned with the mortgage business party. Because if there are flaws in the settlement, that means public will make them pay. buygooglepluses.com

He said the new government should address ‘infrastructural challenges’ and one of the key avenues of achieving this task is through “Economic recovery and growth is dependent on infrastructural development. Considering the current financial position of the incoming government, it becomes falvit

This is best site to spent time on .I just stumbled upon your chatty blog and desired to say that I have really enjoyed reading your very well written blog posts. I will be your frequent visitor, that's for sure. sky customer services number

car insurance companies
I should say only that its awesome! The blog is informational and always produce amazing things.

Please let me know if you're looking for a article author for your weblog. I agree with you

Great post.Thank you for taking the time to posting this information very helpfull!. I discovered so many interesting things inside your blog especially. - parfum pria terbaik

The program can even be operated fully by the public. The Illinois State Police operate their own program using cameras to ticket dangerous speeders near highway work sites. That program has been without controversy. elixir du suedois

The cash-strapped city is glad for the extra revenue and brags that compliance with housing code is on the rise. http://www.jmtrade.net.pl/

The Illinois State Police operate their own program using cameras to ticket dangerous speeders near highway work sites. Lease to own POS System

This is my first opportunity to visit this website I found some interesting things and I will apply to the development of my blog. free minecraft accounts

resulting in higher design risk, higher design and system cost, longer time to market, and compromised reliability. Gateworks has introduced several families of Network hipoteczne24.pl

he time to posting this information very helpfull!. I discovered so many inte website design

should say only that its awesome! The blog is informational and always produce amazing things. http://www.lisaolson.org.uk/

I should say only that its awesome! The blog is informational and always produce amazing things falvit

They contract with another company that installs cameras in the red lights at busy intersections. After turning right at a red light without coming to a complete stop behind the line, the company sends you a ticket in the mail for $156.soundcloud downloader

installs cameras in the red lights at busy intersections. After turning right at a re link

As many as 700 communities across as many as 28 states contract out to private companies that install and operate automated red-light or speed cameras and then send tickets to the owners of cars caught on film for legal violations. soundcloud downloader

Pages

Priority Action

The overuse of antibiotics on factory farms is threatening the effectiveness of lifesaving antibiotics. Call on the Food and Drug Administration to put an end to the worst practices.

Support Us

Your donation supports U.S. PIRG’s work to stand up for consumers on the issues that matter, especially when powerful interests are blocking progress.

Consumer Alerts

Join our network and stay up to date on our campaigns, get important consumer updates and take action on critical issues.